Fred-Rick
2 min readApr 15, 2023

--

I tried but did not find anything that you described, Alexandre.

--

We differ in our big picture, which is fine, but it also means our discussion is not straight at one another's idea.

Let me show you the three structural possibilities how we could have gotten here. There are no other possibilities.

1/ New from Nothing

2/ Full New from Full Old

3/ Partial New from (Partial of) Old

I hope you see that there are no other structures available to explain our material universe.

#1 is almost not worth talking about. It is very illogical. Even those that cling to all-from-nothing have a starting point in quantum fluctuation fields, so something was there already.

I have to reject #1 as an infantile structure.

#2 is a much better structure. However, there is one flaw that makes it impossible. If 100% Old became 100% New, then 100% New will revert to 100% Old in fifteen minutes max.

One cannot have an outcome based on whatever independent state, this being 100%, and this not reverting to what it was prior. Something had to give, otherwise the result could not have been established for long.

#3 is the only structure left

[if you see other structures? Please divulge.]

The original state had an ability that ended up costing that original state its setup. The toy broke and lost its special ability (that ultimately undermined itself); like a toy car driving off a cliff and then not driving any longer, ever.

We do not need to declare what the egg was, but when we witness an omelet we know that there was an egg. Plus, that egg broke.

Plus, the shell pieces of the egg are not baked in with the omelet.

So, we have A and B.

A is non-linear. B is linear, even though B is augmented with the non-linear electrons.

We therefore have three states from one prior state:

1/ quarks -> neutrons and protons: linear.

2/ negative electrons pulled in to neutralize the positive charges of the protons fully: non-linear.

3/ the remainder of the original state: non-linear, non-material.

All three realms are no longer stretching themselves to one universal outcome. Even #3 is not much larger than a galaxy.

So, did the prior state had an ability to 'shoot itself in the foot'?

Yes.

But just the foot became linear, i.e. damaged.

--

--

Fred-Rick
Fred-Rick

No responses yet